The recent oil shale forum at CMU was designed to provide continued dialogue on domestic oil shale development and for the most part, the forum accomplished its mission.

However, one area of the panel forum that fell short was led by Sen. Mark Udall's brother, Randy Udall. What could've been a productive discussion on environmental concerns was overshadowed by Randy's lack of facts, outrageous hyperbole and condescending tone. Environmental concerns need to be addressed as industry develops, but unfortunately, Mr. Udall was more about the show than substance.

In contrast, kudos must be given to panelists Jim Spehar and Jeremy Boak, as well as the host and moderator, Teresa Coons.

Though baseline projections, in Spehar's presentation, appear to assume all industries in the region would be operating at maximum capacity, both the positive economic impacts and potential strains placed on infrastructure were highlighted.

Likewise, Dr. Boak of the Colorado School of Mines, shared his vast knowledge of geology and the technologies being explored by companies working on commercial development.

In addition to replacing the rather inflammatory emotion-laden rhetoric of Mr. Udall with a more unbiased source, the other item that would have added to the panel would have been, a voice from the oil shale industry. Their perspective on technology, socioeconomic and environmental impacts and also regulations from the federal government would have been very interesting and insightful.

Overall, this was a positive event and I commend Teresa Coons, the Math and Science Center and their Youth Policy Summit for hosting the event.

Our nation needs to continue constructive discussions about all energy options as we work toward energy independence, and oil shale needs to be a major part of our nation's much needed energy plan.